I’m a web designer, so I have a stake in this. I’ll be fair anyway, because a site builder really is the right call for some people, and hiring someone isn’t always worth it.
The three ways to get a site
DIY site builder
Wix, Squarespace, GoDaddy and the newer AI builders
Best for tight budgets, simple sites and owners who like tinkering. You pay a monthly fee and do the work yourself. Cheapest in cash, most expensive in evenings.
Freelancer, one-time build
A custom design, then it’s handed to you
Best for a custom look on a set budget, if you or someone you trust can handle hosting, security and updates afterward. Changes are often billed by the hour.
Managed monthly plan
Someone builds it, then keeps running it
Best for owners who want it handled. One monthly price covers the build, hosting, changes and often your Google listing. Check the term, what’s included and what you keep if you leave.
Side by side
- Cash: builders run about $15–50 a month. A freelancer often charges $1,500–5,000 up front, plus hosting. Managed plans are roughly $99–349 a month (that’s my range; others charge less or more). The three-year math is in what a small business website costs.
- Your time: with a builder, every hour is yours, including every update for years. With a freelancer, updates fall back to you unless you pay per change. With a managed plan, you give input at the start, then send an email when something changes.
- Look: builder templates are polished but shared by many other sites. A designer can start from your business instead of from a template.
- Speed and search control: builders handle the basics, but limit what you can change under the hood. A hand-built site can be tuned page by page.
- Leaving: builder sites are hard or impossible to move to another host. A freelancer or managed plan should hand over your files and domain if you leave. Get that in writing.
Where site builders fall short
Builders have gotten genuinely good. Wix and Squarespace sites can rank, load reasonably quickly and look professional. These are trade-offs to know before you commit, not reasons to panic.
- Speed you can only partly control. Google measures real visitors’ experience with Core Web Vitals: how fast the main content shows up (good is within 2.5 seconds), how quickly the page responds to a tap (under 200 milliseconds), and how much the layout jumps while loading. A builder loads its own platform code on your pages, and you can’t strip it out, so there’s a limit to how far you can tune. Test any site, yours or a competitor’s, free at pagespeed.web.dev.
- Speed isn’t everything, though. Google says it always tries to show the most relevant content, even if the page experience is sub-par. A slow, useful page can beat a fast, empty one.
- Search settings that are good enough until they aren’t. Page titles, descriptions and redirects are usually covered. Deeper control, like structured data, how pages are built and which scripts load, varies by platform and plan.
- Sameness. Popular templates are shared by many sites, and AI builders tend to produce similar layouts from similar prompts. Customers may not notice, but you won’t stand out either.
- Time. The monthly fee is the small cost. The big one is the evenings spent writing, fixing photos and working out why the phone version looks off, then keeping it all current.
- Lock-in. Wix says its sites can’t be moved to another host. Squarespace can export some content to a WordPress file, but not everything: store pages, style settings and custom CSS stay behind. You can always take your domain with you, but moving the site usually means rebuilding it.
- Add-on fees. Bookings, email at your own domain, removing the builder’s branding and selling online often sit on higher plans or come as paid extras. Price the plan you’ll actually need, and check what it renews at.
When a builder is the right answer
- You’re just starting and need something live this week on a tiny budget.
- You enjoy it, and you’ll really keep it updated.
- It’s a short-term project, like an event or a pop-up.
- Your site is a digital business card, and that’s all it needs to be.
If that’s you, go for it. Use your own domain, keep it registered in your name, and fill in your Google listing too.
Stores and online ordering: use the specialists
This is where I steer almost everyone to a platform, my own clients included. Selling online isn’t a page with a Buy button. Behind it are card payments, sales tax, inventory, shipping, refunds, receipts and fraud checks, plus the card industry’s security rules for handling payments, known as PCI DSS.
Shopify, Square and similar platforms already do all of that and keep it up to date. Shopify, for example, says it’s certified to PCI DSS Level 1, the highest level. A one-person shop like mine rebuilding that from scratch would be slower, riskier and more expensive for you.
So here’s how I handle it: if you sell products or take orders online, the store or ordering system runs on a platform like Shopify or Square, on your own account, and I connect it to your site so it feels like one business. You pay the platform directly, and I don’t mark it up or take a commission. More on what that looks like on the services page.
Questions to help you decide
- How many hours a month will I really spend on this, and what’s an hour of my time worth?
- Will I still be updating it in two years?
- Do I need a store, bookings or online ordering, and which platform will run that part?
- If I outgrow this, can I take the site with me, or only the domain?
If you decide to hire someone, take these twelve questions to ask a web designer to the first call.
Accurate as of October 2026. The companies and services named in this guide change their tools and rules often, so check their own help pages before acting on anything here. This is general information, not legal or professional advice, and Widget Weasel isn’t affiliated with or endorsed by any company it mentions.





